The Black Captain Americas Part 1: Why Isaiah Bradley is More Important than Sam Wilson


The Black Captain Americas Part 1: Why Isaiah Bradley is More Important than Sam Wilson

(this post was first posted on tumblr)

The 2014 re-incarnation of Sam Wilson as Captain America is not the first time Falcon  has picked up the shield. In the comic book verse Sam has been Captain America before. Also, there has been an argument going around the web since then that Isaiah Bradley, not Sam Wilson was the first Black Captain America in the comic verse. Actually, that is both true and false. In terms of publication, yes, Sam was revealed as Captain America about 5 years before Isaiah in Captain America #117 (1969). But in terms of timeline, Isaiah’s storyline in Truth: Red, White and Black (2003) which begins back in World War 2 , predates Sam Wilsons’, whose storyline starts in the ‘70s’ and for most African-Americans Isaiah’s story was more meaningful.

Before I go any further, I just want to point out that yes, I give credit to Marvel for Sam Wilson’s Falcon being one of the first Black Comic Book characters printed in a major publication. (1969) And I am not discrediting that fact. What I’m discussing here is the impact of the archetype of “Black Captain America” and why I feel Isaiah’s character is more important. (more after the jump)

Sam Wilson was sort of the “sidekick” to Steve Rogers’ Cap (who could speak to his spirit animal Redwing telepathically, who was actually a falcon), and stepped up when Cap was down. However, Isaiah Bradley was unwittingly injected with the the Super Soldier serum while he was a soldier in a program that paralleled the true life story of the Tuskegee Experiment. Someone had a “bastard copy” of Erkine’s experiment, and they decided to test it on African-American soldiers at that time, being that they were considered less valuable (read: “less than human”) anyway.

isaiah bradley, captain america, theblerdgurl

After Isaiah knows he’s been enhanced, he reluctantly goes after Nazi’s, (the US gov’t. subtly threaten his family a la Mike Peterson/DEATHLOK AOS) in a secret mission to fight them behind enemy lines. He completes his mission, however, he gets captured and becomes a POW, kind of disavowed and almost killed. When he finally gets out, the US court marshalls him for going AWOL and trying to impersonate Captain America. Eventually, with help from his wife he is pardoned.

THAT is what sets Isaiah’s character apart from Sam’s in many ways and why his character has meant more to African-Americans (especially Black male comic book readers) in this country. It talks about a time that no one wants to talk about when African American men were subjected to a form of institutionalized chemical warfare. A time in which art, imitated a very ugly truth. In the seven part series of the same name, Isaiah crosses paths with public figures (Malcolm X, Muhammad Ali, Nelson Mandela ) and other superheroes (Wolverine, Steve Rogers), but only the Black supers (Luke Cage, Goliath, Pulsar) know who he is and know his importance. He becomes a legend…but only in the Black community. Other white characters have no idea who he is and the government has sworn Isaiah into secrecy, so he can never speak about what or who he is. Eventually, Steve Rogers finds out and uncovers the truth.

isaiah bradley, captain america, theblerdgurl

I give credit to Axel Alonzo and Joe Queseda at Marvel for even attempting to tell Isaiah’s story and for defending it when critics, (and racists) tried to tear it to pieces. The series was written by Robert Morales and drawn by Kyle Baker

Subsequently, Isaiah Bradley’s legacy lives on in his son Josiah X, (a.k.a.- “Justice”) and grandson Eli, who is part of the Marvel’s Young Avenger’s. I will talk about their characters in another posting. Thanks for reading! 🙂

isaiah bradley, captain america, theblerdgurl


1. Isaiah’s Bradley as Captain America in “The Truth: Red, White and Black”

2. Sam Wilson as Captain America in “Sentinel of Liberty”

3. The Black Super Soldiers from “The Truth: Red, White and Black”

4. SteveRogers find out about Elijah and his story. (this panel will never NOT be funny) LOL!

5. Isaiah Bradley Card from the “Marvels War of Heroes” series


  • John Bernard Robinson June 14, 2016 at 10:34 am

    Excellent article and an eye opener for those who wouldn’t otherwise have known due to lack of promotion or what have you. Thank you for this!

  • […] Captain America, Wolverine and Thor? Why not just make new ones? Or at least bring back old ones (Isaiah Bradley, Josiah X or the Patriot?) And how come Riri won’t be called Iron Maiden, or Iron Girl or even […]

  • […] I mentioned in Part 1, after Isaiah Bradley’s dramatic rescue and return to the US in 1943, the US Government had him […]

  • Leave a Reply

    I accept the Privacy Policy

    Order My Book!

    protectors of wakanda, theblerdgurl, karma horne, dora milaje

    Hi! I'm Karama! I'm a Brooklyn blerd, journalist and content creator fueled by coffee and comics. Anime is my orientation. Read More